Wednesday, 20 July 2011
Marx e Hegel. Contributi a una rilettura
Author: Cesarale, Giorgio
Source: Historical Materialism, Volume 19, Number 1, 2011 , pp. 288-303(16)
Abstract:In Marx e Hegel. Contributi a una rilettura, Roberto Fineschi examines the complex relation between Marx and Hegel. According to Fineschi, Marx's relation to Hegel changed over time: in the early period, Marx understood Hegel to be theorising a self-consciousness that in-itself generates reality; while, in his maturity, Marx interpreted Hegel as a more rigorous theoretician of a conceptual Darstellung based on the transition from abstract to concrete. This review-article discusses Fineschi's thesis, according to which Marx's `materialistic overturning' of Hegel involves two aspects: the narrowing of the scope of the conceptual development, and the idea that the beginning of Capital is to be understood as being both logical and empirical. We will argue that the first element was, in some ways, also claimed by Hegel and that the second contradicts other characteristics of Marxian theoretical discourse, such as the idea that demonstrative sequences must be governed by necessity and the centrality of the logic of the presupposed-posited.
Document Type: Research article
Publication date: 2011-01-01
Ascanio Bernardeschi. Recensione di Saggi sull’(in)attualità di Marx, Consecutio Rerum, n. 5 /2018, Marx Inattuale, a cura di Riccardo Bellofiore e Carla Maria Fabiani, Edizioni Efesto, Roma, pp.541, € 20,00. Visibile anche su (http://www.consecutio.org)
Ascanio Bernardeschi. Recensione di Saggi sull’(in)attualità di Marx, Consecutio Rerum, n. 5 /2018, Marx Inattuale, a cura di Riccardo Bell...